Tuesday, December 16, 2008

when science is really worth it

If you manage to make it to the 22nd page of this paper*, you'll read one of the most entertaining paragraphs in the history of science. (By the way MS is "mortality salience," which basically means being confronted with the inevitability of your own death.)
More recently, Solomon, Pyszczynski, Cohen and Ogilvie (in press) demonstrated that a reminder of death increased peoples’ reports of flying fantasies and desire to fly; a behavior that, for humans without mechanical assistance, clearly violates the laws of nature. As importantly, asking people to imagine themselves flying eliminated a widely replicated MS-induced worldview defense. Specifically, whereas MS increased affection for President Bush among American participants relative to controls (replicating Landau et al., 2004b), imagining oneself flying completely eliminated this effect. These results are shown in Figure 2.
Here is the amazing Figure 2:


Please share with me your favorite part about the paragraph or the figure. I think my favorite part is the implication that if you ever find yourself in the upsetting condition of feeling affectionate towards George Bush, just imagine yourself flying and you'll be cured.


* Landau, M. J., Solomon, S., Pyszczynski, T., & Greenberg, J. (2007). On the compatibility of terror management theory and perspectives on human evolution. Evolutionary Psychology, 5, 476-519.

6 comments:

Holly Cummings said...

that's rich. and what a random research topic!

Brice Lord said...

Well, there's correlation and then there's causation, right? Any indication in the paper on this?

chuck zoi said...

I didn't actually go read the original paper. Are you saying that in regards to my comment about curing yourself, or about the main observation in the quoted paragraph? (cause mine was just a joke)

Brice Lord said...

Specifically this part:

"Specifically, whereas MS increased affection for President Bush among American participants relative to controls (replicating Landau et al., 2004b), imagining oneself flying completely eliminated this effect."

"Eliminated" is confusing. In other words, does imagining oneself flying cause a relatively decreased affection for President Bush or is it correlated with something that blocks the ability to feel the affection?

chuck zoi said...

When people were reminded of their own mortality, they tended to view Bush more favorably than those who weren't given the MS prime. If they were asked to imagine themselves flying first, there was no difference in Bush affection between groups. Does that make sense?

Brice Lord said...

Ah, yes, it does, thanks.